The 2024 NFL Combine kicks off this week, meaning #DraftTwitter is heating up to give you every take on the rookie class. We gave our readers a Fantasy Football SuperFlex 2024 Dynasty Rookie Mock Draft back in early January, but with the college football season, early declares, and the Senior Bowl now in the past, it’s time to freshen it up before things get silly at the NFL Combine.
Unfortunately, Caleb Williams, Jayden Daniels, Marvin Harrison Jr., and Malik Nabers will not participate in the NFL Combine events. Still, we should see most of the top rookie prospects run around in their underwear this week.
With 2024 dynasty rookie content in full swing, bookmark our Fantasy Stock Watch for our Rookie Draft Profiles and Scouting Reports. Also, be sure to read our 2024 Dynasty Rookie Rankings and Top-75 SuperFlex Big Board, which will be constantly updated throughout the draft process.
Let’s dive in.
2024 DYNASTY ROOKIE MOCK DRAFT
FIRST ROUND
1.01: CALEB WILLIAMS, QB, SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA
To make things simple, Caleb Williams is the complete package with the football in his hands.
Sure, he cried in his mommy’s arms after losing a regular season game and made some questionable comments to the media this year, but he can easily make all the throws and avoid rushers. His top-notch ball placement allows receivers not to lose stride after the catch. His accuracy also thrives off-platform and in the field’s intermediate and deep areas.
Outside of trying to do too much at times, which leads to unnecessary turnovers, he’s the perfect fantasy franchise quarterback with immense dynasty upside. Unfortunately, he will not throw at the NFL Combine and will only meet with teams.
2023 stats: 3,633 yds, 30 TD, 5 INT, 68.6%, 136 ruYD, 11 ruTD
1.02: MARVIN HARRISON JR, WR, OHIO STATE
Previously: Unchanged
Marvin Harrison Jr., hailed as one of the premier draft prospects of his era, embodies the epitome of a future NFL star. Standing tall at 6-foot-4 and weighing 205 lbs, he combines imposing size with blazing speed, clocking in at an impressive 22.2 mph.
His accolades, including being a Heisman finalist and recipient of the Biletnikoff Award, underscore his elite talents as a receiver, projecting him as an immediate alpha WR1 in the NFL with the potential to rank among the top 10 wide receivers as a rookie.
Throughout his final collegiate season, Harrison showcased his ability to thrive under pressure despite facing a notable decline in quarterback performance, maintaining an average of over 18 yards per reception. He consistently delivered crucial plays, elevating the Buckeye offense with his exceptional athleticism and reliability.
While comparisons may arise, particularly with Malik Nabers, Harrison’s remarkable skill set, characterized by his unmatched speed, hands, and ability to win contested catches, sets him apart as a generational talent destined for fantasy greatness.
Despite opting out of testing at the NFL Combine and Ohio State Pro Day, Harrison’s trajectory as a dominant force in the NFL remains undeniable, following in the footsteps of his Hall of Fame father, Marvin Harrison.
2023 stats: 67 rec, 1,211 yds, 14 TD, 18.1 avg
1.03: DRAKE MAYE, QB, NORTH CAROLINA
Previously: Unchanged
With Jayden Daniels getting some buzz, there will be competition for the overall and dynasty rookie QB2. Daniels, who is coming off a historic Heisman season, is the pre-NFL Draft darling right now, while Drake Maye’s game is nit-picked by the talking heads.
If I’m on the board and Williams and Harrison Jr. are selected, I’m still going with Maye if I need a quarterback. The North Carolina signal-caller is a stud with all the tools of a franchise quarterback.
Maye, who stands at 6-foot-4, 230 lbs, was created in a lab to play quarterback in 2023. He has elite arm talent to make all the throws and can hurt defenses with his mobility inside and outside the pocket. He throws a better deep ball and has better ball placement downfield than Caleb Williams. He also resembles Patrick Mahomes/ Josh Allen’s creativity, making him exciting to watch but prone to some head-scratching turnovers.
Maye is the next Justin Herbert with this blend of a huge arm and athleticism in and out of the pocket.
2023 stats: 3,608 yds, 24 TD, 9 INT, 63.3%, 449 ruYD, 9 ruTD
1.04: JAYDEN DANIELS, QB, LSU
Previously: 1.05
The Heisman Trophy winner is the greatest riser in our rookie mock draft, going from unranked to 1.05 to 1.04 in just a few months. He’ll also likely be the most significant riser in the NFL Draft, going from a mid-to-late-round pick to a top-five pick.
While the knock on him is he only had “one year of production,” that’s just blatantly false. While he officially exploded this year, the dual-threat quarterback put up 20 total touchdowns to two interceptions as a freshman at Arizona State.
Over his five-year college career between ASU and LSU, Daniels amassed 3,307 rushing yards and 34 rushing touchdowns, along with 12,749 passing yards and 89 passing touchdowns. He capped a terrific collegiate career in 2023 with 50 total touchdowns, four interceptions, a 72.2 completion percentage, and over 1,100 yards rushing.
While he only had one year of truly elite production, look at someone like Joe Burrow, who did absolutely nothing until his final season at LSU. The 23-year-old has five years of experience and has evolved as both a passer and a runner — making him a sure-fire top-five draft pick and dynasty rookie selection.
Jayden Daniels is stress-free Caleb Williams, who will make fewer mistakes but drips in similar upside. But similar to Williams, Daniels will not throw at the NFL Combine and will only meet with teams.
2023 stats: 3,812 yds, 40 TD, 4 INT, 72.2%, 1,134 ruYD, 10 ruTD
1.05: MALIK NABERS, WR, LSU
Previously: 1.04
Malik Nabers emerges as a beacon of promise for those outside the top three in dynasty drafts, offering a tantalizing consolation prize after Marvin Harrison Jr. The LSU standout, often overshadowed by another elite talent in his class, would have easily claimed the WR1 title in most other years.
Throughout his collegiate career, Nabers has thrived as Daniels’ primary target, showcasing his versatility and playmaking prowess. This season alone, he amassed over 1,500 yards and secured 14 touchdown receptions on 89 catches, solidifying his status as a dynamic force on the field.
Nabers epitomizes the modern-day playmaker, seamlessly adapting to various roles within the offense and proving to be a mismatch nightmare for opposing defenses. With the ability to line up on the outside or dominate from the slot, his fluidity and explosiveness make him a constant threat to break open a game.
Despite comparisons with Harrison Jr., Nabers’ superior after-the-catch ability and overall versatility suggest that the gap between the two future stars may not be as wide as perceived. With the potential for future fantasy WR1 status and an immediate impact anticipated in his rookie season, Nabers stands poised to leave an indelible mark on dynasty leagues.
Nabers will not test or run until LSU Pro Day on March 27.
2023 stats: 86 rec, 1,546 yds, 14 TD, 18.0 avg
1.06: BROCK BOWERS, TE, GEORGIA
Previously: Unchanged
Brock Bowers is a generational tight end prospect, showcasing an elite skill set that could transcend the position.
Hailing from Georgia, Bowers possesses a rare blend of speed and size that sets him apart as a nightmare matchup for opposing defenses. Reminiscent of Rob Gronkowski, he seamlessly combines his catching abilities with an uncanny knack for yards after catch, consistently turning routine receptions into game-altering moments.
Bowers’ dominance extends beyond his receiving prowess, as evidenced by his remarkable PFF advanced statistics, boasting unparalleled grades in categories such as receiving yards, touchdowns, and yards after contact.
Bowers continues to carve his path to greatness, but his potential remains largely untapped, a prospect that instills fear in opponents and excitement in fans alike. From his remarkable freshman campaign at Athens to his ongoing collegiate achievements, Bowers’ journey exemplifies a player destined for greatness in the NFL and beyond — making him a can’t-miss fantasy prospect.
2023 stats: 56 rec, 714 yds, 6 TD, 12.8 avg (10 games)
1.07: ROME ODUNZE, WR, WASHINGTON
Previously: Unchanged
Rome Odunze landed in our second tier of wide receivers by himself, behind Harrison Jr. and Nabers, but he is another future NFL WR1 that drips in elite alpha upside. Odunze posted back-to-back 1,000-yard seasons and totaled 20 touchdowns over that span as the top target on Washington’s crowded target totem pole.
Odunze makes plays downfield, evidenced by his 18 receptions of 20-plus air yards. He’s the best-contested catch receiver in the class, with a 74.1% contested catch rate. It’s not a 50/50 ball with Odunze because he’s likely coming down with the football.
Looking and playing like the prototypical X wide receiver, Odunze is a big, physical wideout with strong hands and a crazy catch radius. He makes up for his lack of vertical speed with his smooth route running and natural ability to pluck the ball out of any situation.
Odunze lucked out with Michael Pennix Jr. as his quarterback, but his catch radius and skill set almost make him quarterback-proof in the NFL — with shades of Mike Evans or Courtland Sutton as comps.
The former Husky is a future WR1 with massive weekly fantasy upside.
2023 stats: 81 rec, 1,428 yds, 13 TD, 17.6 avg
1.08: BRIAN THOMAS JR, WR, LSU
Previously: 1.09
Brian Thomas Jr. emerges as a potential game-changer in the NFL, a fact underscored by his standout performance during his junior season at LSU, where he served as Jayden Daniels’ dynamic WR2 alongside Nabers.
Blessed with elite straight-line acceleration and speed, Thomas Jr. poses a vertical mismatch for any defense. His exceptional leaping ability and body control further enhance his repertoire, enabling him to excel in contested catches and dominate in the end zone. While his current game primarily revolves around deep threats and jump ball situations, the 6-foot-4 wideout possesses immense potential for growth and versatility.
With further development, he stands poised to evolve into a well-rounded receiver capable of delivering consistent performances beyond his typical vertical targets. With his natural talent and untapped ceiling, Thomas presents a compelling project for any team, specifically one with a vertical passing game. He offers a high floor alongside the potential for explosive plays and touchdown-scoring prowess.
Thomas Jr. is a tantalizing prospect for NFL and dynasty fantasy football.
2023 stats: 68 rec, 1,177 yds, 17 TD, 17.3 avg
1.09: KEON COLEMAN, WR, FLORIDA STATE
Previously: 1.08
Keon Coleman’s journey from the struggling offense of Michigan State to the explosive ranks of Florida State showcased his ability to adapt and excel on a national stage. His standout debut for FSU, amassing 122 yards and three touchdowns against LSU, catapulted him into the spotlight, demonstrating his potential as a game-changing talent.
Despite moments of brilliance throughout his final season, highlighted by impressive performances like his nine receptions for 140 yards and a touchdown coupled with 107 punt return yards against Syracuse, Coleman also faced challenges, including games where he struggled to make an impact, such as his zero-reception outing against Boston College and multiple games with minimal receptions.
While Coleman’s size, athleticism, and natural abilities position him as a likely first-round pick, his journey to becoming a consistent fantasy option hinges on the continued development and refinement of his skill set. His reliance on athleticism over consistent separation poses a challenge he must overcome to maximize his potential in the NFL.
As evaluators assess his pre-draft performances, Coleman’s trajectory remains uncertain, with the potential to soar up the rankings or face setbacks like Quentin Johnston. Despite the inherent risks, Coleman’s immense upside makes him a compelling prospect worth considering for those willing to roll the dice on his talent and potential.
2023 stats: 50 rec, 658 yds, 11 TD, 13.2 avg
1.10: TROY FRANKLIN, WR, OREGON
Previously: Unchanged
Troy Franklin emerges as a towering presence on the field, combining his lanky frame with lightning speed and a knack for explosive plays, crucial in propelling Bo Nix’s offense to new heights in 2023.
Standing at 6-foot-3, Franklin embodies the archetype of a deep threat, poised to leave defenders in his wake with projected speeds in the 4.3s. Beyond his ability to stretch the field vertically, he possesses remarkable agility and elusiveness, capable of turning short receptions into electrifying gains, leaving defenders grasping at air.
PFF data highlights Franklin’s prowess, with an impressive tally of 37 explosive plays exceeding 15 yards and 14 missed tackles forced, showcasing his ability to thrive in open space. What sets Franklin apart is his versatility, demonstrated by his proficiency in intermediate routes and his adeptness at winning contested jump balls, adding a new dimension to his game.
While his primary impact lies in his role as a vertical weapon and exceptional ball tracker, his potential as a fantasy WR2 with substantial ‘boom’ potential evokes comparisons to a more refined Gabe Davis, promising a blend of natural talent and consistency. As the anticipation builds leading up to rookie dynasty drafts, Franklin’s draft stock could skyrocket, positioning him as a coveted day-one impact player, particularly if he finds himself in a high-octane offense like Buffalo or Kansas City.
2023 stats: 81 rec, 1,383 yds, 14 TD, 17.1 avg
1.11: ADONAI MITCHELL, WR, TEXAS
Previously: Unchanged
Adonai Mitchell’s impact as part of the formidable trio alongside Quinn Ewers and Xavier Worthy played a pivotal role in Texas’ remarkable College Football Playoff journey, culminating in a season marked by unstoppable offensive prowess.
Mitchell’s track record speaks for itself, boasting two national titles while at Georgia and playing a crucial role in Texas’ CFP berth. Demonstrating his versatility, Mitchell proved lethal against single coverage, recording an impressive six touchdowns under such circumstances in 2023, showcasing his ability to thrive in various offensive schemes.
Utilized primarily as a vertical threat during his tenure at Georgia, Mitchell’s repertoire has evolved to include a more diverse route tree, capitalizing on his blend of size and athleticism. With a staggering 84.4% of his receptions resulting in first downs, Mitchell emerges as a reliable option capable of delivering game-changing plays in critical moments.
Under the guidance of offensive masterminds Todd Monken at Georgia and Steve Sarkisian at Texas, Mitchell flourished, underscoring his adaptability and potential as a consistent playmaker at the NFL level, with his ceiling yet to be fully realized.
AD Mitchell is a baller and will be a strong fantasy WR2 for the foreseeable future.
2023 stats: 51 rec, 813 yds, 10 TD, 15.9 avg
1.12: XAVIER WORTHY, WR, TEXAS
Previously: Unchanged
Xavier Worthy is one of this class’ most polarizing wide receiver prospects. Fantasy players will see draft experts mocking Worthy from WR4 to WR10 — primarily due to his massive upside, inconsistencies, and lack of size at 6-foot-1, 172 lbs.
Worthy is one of the best short and intermediate route runners in his class, displaying elite short-area quickness and NFL-type releases. Plus, he can burn defensive backs downfield with his blazing speed (22.7 MPH). However, his lack of size (172 lbs) will hurt him on the outside against physical NFL defensive backs.
Still, if drafted into the right spot, he’ll be a fantasy weapon and could be a weekly ‘boom’ option with a very high ceiling.
2023 stats: 75 rec, 1,014 yds, 5 TD, 13.5 avg
SECOND ROUND
2.01: JONATHAN BROOKS, RB, TEXAS
2.02: JJ MCCARTHY, QB, MICHIGAN
2.03: TREY BENSON, RB, FLORIDA ST.
2.04: BRAELON ALLEN, RB, WISCONSIN
2.05: BLAKE CORUM, RB, MICHIGAN
2.06: BUCKY IRVING, RB, OREGON
2.07: MICHAEL PENIX JR., QB, WASHINGTON
2.08: BO NIX, QB, OREGON
2.09: XAVIER LEGETTE, WR, SOUTH CAROLINA
2.10: LADD MCCONKEY, WR, GEORGIA
