The 2026 fantasy football dynasty rookie class is top-heavy at wide receiver, but one question is already dominating dynasty draft rooms: Who deserves the WR1 crown between Makai Lemon, Carnell Tate, and Jordyn Tyson?
Each brings a different flavor to the table. Lemon offers elite reliability and route polish after a Biletnikoff-winning breakout. Tate brings an Ohio State pedigree, refined intermediate dominance, and big-play verticality. Tyson counters with explosive playmaking, vertical juice, and proven production. When you’re on the clock in dynasty rookie drafts, this isn’t just a preference debate, it’s a franchise-defining decision.
In this breakdown, we’ll compare Makai Lemon vs Carnell Tate vs Jordyn Tyson through an NFL Draft and fantasy football dynasty lens: production profiles, film traits, projected draft capital, and long-term ceiling outcomes. Who projects as the safest WR1 for dynasty managers? Who has the highest fantasy upside? And which receiver could see his stock swing the most during the pre-draft process?
WHAT’S NEW AT RSJ?
READ: CJay’s 2026 Dynasty Rookie Rankings: Top 70 SuperFlex Big Board
READ: Tanner’s 2026 NFL Draft Rookie Rankings: Pre-Combine Top-60 Big Board & Tiers
READ: The Wolf’s Updated 2026 Fantasy Football Rankings & Big Board
Let’s settle the WR1 debate.
MAKAI LEMON, USC (RSJ: NO. 3 OVERALL, WR1)
MAKAI LEMON PRODUCTION
Makai Lemon showed up in Los Angeles as a headline name in USC’s 2023 recruiting class, carrying a 247 four-star composite grade and the expectations that come with it.
As a true freshman, he flashed his versatility immediately, appearing in nine games and even logging snaps on both sides of the ball. His stat line (six catches for 88 yards) was modest, but the juice was obvious.
In his second season, Lemon wasn’t just a contributor; he was a focal point. He paced the Trojans with 52 receptions for 764 yards and three touchdowns in 12 games, while also emerging as one of the most dangerous kick returners in college football. His 1,460 all-purpose yards that season highlighted just how many ways he could tilt the field.
Then came the breakout. In 2025, Lemon exploded for 79 catches, 1,156 receiving yards, and 11 touchdowns, posting five games of over 125 receiving yards and consistently taking over on Saturdays. He captured the Biletnikoff Award as the nation’s top wide receiver, and over his final two seasons dropped just three passes on 175 targets. That kind of efficiency doesn’t just get noticed, it gets circled in red ink by NFL scouts. By the end of his junior year, Lemon had firmly established himself as the top wide receiver prospect in this year’s draft class by Roto Street Journal.
MAKAI LEMON SCOUTING REPORT
Lemon is a compact, explosive playmaker with elite run-after-catch ability and the temperament of a running back once the ball is in his hands. He plays with a low center of gravity, bounces off contact, and attacks defenders in space. Routine touches, such as slants, crossers, and screens quickly turn into chunk plays.
He fits the modern slot-dominant mold, winning with nuance, leverage, and football IQ rather than pure track speed or towering size. At 5-foot-11, he consistently plays bigger than his frame, attacking the catch point with strength and confidence. His route pacing, ability to manipulate defenders, and strong hands make him quarterback-friendly from Day 1. Lemon doesn’t just get open, he understands how to get open.
Due to this skill-set, Lemon will rack up targets early in his NFL career. He diagnoses coverages on the fly and instinctively settles into soft spots against zone. But, he’s not limited to underneath work. Lemon tracks the ball naturally downfield and competes through contact, making him a viable option on boundary shots. He may project more as a high-volume chain-mover than a true field-tilter, but there’s enough vertical pop to keep defenses honest.
MAKAI LEMON BREAKDOWN & SUMMARY
Makai Lemon enters the NFL Draft as one of the safest wide receiver prospects on the board. Three drops on 175 targets tell you all you need to know about his hands. Winning the Biletnikoff confirms he can dominate at the highest level of college football.
However, the NFL transition won’t be without challenges. Longer, more physical press corners will test him early, but his polish, competitiveness, and reliability give him a strong floor. Expect him to carve out real offensive reps as a rookie with full-time starter upside right away.
Some wide receivers require a scheme overhaul to shine. Lemon slides into what you already run, and quietly upgrades it.
CARNELL TATE, OHIO STATE (RSJ: NO. 4 OVERALL, WR2)
CARNELL TATE PRODUCTION
Carnell Tate arrived in Columbus as a five-star standout from IMG Academy and wasted no time carving out a role in the nation’s deepest and most talented wide receiver room. Coached by wide receiver guru Brian Hartline, Tate stepped into a program that has become an NFL factory for WR talent, and held his own from Day 1.
As a true freshman in 2023, Tate appeared in all 13 games, finishing with 18 receptions for 264 yards and a touchdown. The stat line may not scream breakout, but burning your redshirt as a freshman at Ohio State is rare air. Unless you’re a unicorn like Jeremiah Smith, it’s not normal for a true freshman to earn quality playing time.
In 2024, Tate took the next step, becoming a full-time starter during Ohio State’s national championship run. Lining up opposite future first-round pick Emeka Egbuka and alongside Smith, Tate posted 52 catches for 733 yards and four touchdowns across 15 starts. And when defenses tilted coverage toward Smith, Tate made them pay, highlighted by a seven-catch, 87-yard performance against Texas in the CFP semifinal.
His final season is where his NFL Draft stock truly caught fire. Tate added a vertical and more physical edge to his game, showing he could win beyond the intermediate level. Even while missing three games with a calf strain, he recorded career highs with 51 receptions, 875 yards, and nine touchdowns, averaging 17.2 yards per catch. He evolved into a true big-play weapon, averaging 32.5 yards per touchdown with five scores from 40-plus yards out.
By the end of the year, Tate earned second-team All-American honors and positioned himself to become the fifth consecutive Ohio State wide receiver selected in the first round of the NFL Draft. In a program stacked with NFL talent, Tate didn’t just blend in with the five-stars; he leveled up.
CARNELL TATE SCOUTING REPORT
Turn on the tape, and Tate wins with polish. Don’t be fooled by the high YPC. He’s not a pure burner; he’s a craftsman from the Hartline School of Route Running. His game is built on timing, route discipline, and an advanced understanding of how to attack leverage. Rather than relying solely on highlight-reel vertical shots, Tate profiles as a classic X receiver or movement Z who thrives in the intermediate windows where NFL quarterbacks make their money.
He’s excellent at manipulating defenders at the top of his routes, toe-tapping on the sideline, tracking the football downfield, and bodying corners on jump balls. That combination gives him a clear runway for early starting snaps. The debate evaluators will have: Is he a true alpha WR1, or an elite complementary weapon, similar to his role alongside Jeremiah Smith?
After earning his Buckeye leaves in Ryan Day’s passing scheme and a year under Chip Kelly, Tate should fit in any scheme. He does his best work in the 10-to-20-yard range, finding space versus zone and converting key third downs. Stylistically, he’s smooth like Chris Olave and Garrett Wilson, but can also go up and get it like Marvin Harrison Jr.
He’ll be able to show off his soft hands and elite route running at the NFL Combine, but his 40-yard dash will be under a microscope since he doesn’t necessarily beat corners with pure straight-line speed.
CARNELL TATE BREAKDOWN & SUMMARY
The résumé checks out: production, pedigree, and technical refinement. Tate shared the field with elite talent throughout his career and still consistently earned targets. That speaks volumes. Add in championship experience, leadership traits, and a strong football IQ, and teams are getting more than just a stat line.
There’s a reassuring floor here, the kind that makes dynasty general managers comfortable on draft night. While he may not carry the rare, game-breaking ceiling of a generational prospect, he projects as a Day 1 contributor with immediate third-down value and the tools to become a steady, productive real-life and fantasy starter for years to come.
JORDYN TYSON, ARIZONA STATE (RSJ: NO. 5 OVERALL, WR3)
JORDYN TYSON PRODUCTION
Jordyn Tyson’s college football journey didn’t start with five-star hype. As a three-star recruit, he signed with Colorado and immediately turned heads as a true freshman in 2022. Tyson led Colorado in receiving with 22 catches for 470 yards and four touchdowns, averaging an impressive 21.4 yards per reception.
His breakout moment? A monster performance against Arizona State, his future squad: 115 receiving yards, a touchdown, plus 131 punt return yards and another score. A 246-yard, two-touchdown afternoon that foreshadowed elite upside in Tempe.
After that electric debut, Tyson transferred to the Sun Devils in 2023. He redshirted while rehabbing a knee injury, learning under WR coach and NFL legend Hines Ward. The patience paid off.
In 2024, Tyson exploded onto the national stage with 75 receptions, 1,101 yards, and 10 touchdowns. He earned third-team All-American honors and Big 12 Offensive Newcomer of the Year. A devastating collarbone injury against rival Arizona cut his CFP campaign short, but by then, NFL scouts already had what they needed on tape.
In 2025, hamstring issues limited him to nine games, yet he still produced 61 catches for 711 yards and eight touchdowns. When healthy, Tyson remained the engine of an Arizona State offense that battled injuries, including to QB Sam Leavitt, all season.
JORDYN TYSON SCOUTING REPORT
Tyson wins with detail, toughness, and a natural feel for the position. He’s not a pure track-star burner; his likely 4.5’ish speed won’t intimidate on paper, but his releases, pacing, and route nuance consistently create real separation. He thrives in the intermediate windows, especially on digs, crossers, and outbreaking routes where timing matters.
Tyson attacks contested catches like he’s boxing out for a rebound, positioning defenders on his hip and finishing through contact. His body control along the boundary and ability to adjust mid-air make him quarterback-friendly in tight coverage.
Versatility is another selling point. Tyson lined up outside, in the slot, and in motion in Kenny Dillingham’s offense, giving offensive coordinators flexibility to move him around the formation. He projects best in offenses built on play-action, timing concepts, and layered intermediate route trees where precision and reliability are valued. And thanks to his development under Hines Ward, he blocks with effort, which should further cement early playing time.
On the flip side, Tyson’s medical history will be scrutinized. Multiple injuries across three seasons mean teams will dig deep during the pre-draft process. To make matters worse, Tyson dropped out of the NFL Combine on-field activities due to a late-November hamstring injury that he’s still recovering from.
JORDYN TYSON BREAKDOWN & SUMMARY
Jordyn Tyson has the profile of a potential NFL and fantasy WR1 if everything clicks. He can win at all three levels, produce in big moments, and elevate an offense when healthy. At minimum, he projects as a strong WR2 in a passing attack. At his ceiling, you’re looking at a Pro Bowl-caliber receiver who can command targets and take over stretches of a game.
The tape against Power Five competition backs it up. The production backs it up. If the medicals check out, Tyson has the tools to be one of the steals or stars of this draft class.
